Summary
Many D2C brands want to work with influencers but without fixed fees. That works when the collaboration is commission-based: the creator earns only when an order comes through their link or code. This article shows what such an offer should contain, how to win creators, which disclosure rules apply in the UK and how tracking works. The legal notes draw on public guidance and are not legal advice.
How does commission-only influencer marketing work?
With commission-only you pay the creator no fixed fee per post, but a share of the sales triggered through a personal link or voucher code. If nothing sells, no commission is due. The creator carries the risk that their effort goes unpaid, so the offer has to be attractive and the terms clear from the start.
The model is an affiliate programme, the same principle that blogs, voucher sites and comparison sites use. For creators it is extra income, for you it is an advertising cost that arises only when sales happen. If you rely on commission alone, adjust your expectations: reach and trust matter more than any single post.
What should you offer creators?
Offer more than a commission: a personal voucher code for their community, product samples to try, a clear brief, quick replies and transparent reporting. Creators choose brands where they feel well looked after. A tidy offer saves both sides questions and shows that you take the collaboration seriously.
The table below shows the building blocks of an offer and what to watch for in each.
| Building block | What you define | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Commission | Rate on the net basket | Work it out against your margin after shipping and returns |
| Code or link | Personal to each creator | Clear attribution in tracking |
| Samples | Product to test | Clarify disclosure, see below |
| Brief | Key messages, no-gos | No false claims or unsupported statements |
| Reporting | Timing and review period | Discuss cancellations and returns openly |
| Term | Length of the collaboration | Set out notice and code handling clearly |
How high should the commission be?
The rate depends on your margin, not on what others pay. Work backwards: what is left after cost of goods, shipping, returns and payment fees, and how much of that will you give up for a new customer? Your rate must carry commission plus the network fee. Choose a fair rate that holds over time.
This article deliberately names no fixed figure, because it depends on sector and margin. The article on commission levels has worked examples. At selecdoo you set the commission yourself, and it is calculated on the net basket.
How do you find suitable creators?
Start with people who already use your products: customers with reach who mention you already. Ask them directly whether a commission-only collaboration suits them. For new contacts, check that their community fits your audience, and look for genuine interaction rather than follower counts alone.
Alternatively you can use curated publishers through a network. At selecdoo, shops do not receive publishers' contact details, and collaboration runs through the platform. selecdoo is now opening to UK brands. How to win publishers is covered on the page about how to recruit affiliates.
What are the disclosure rules in the UK?
Content that is paid for or otherwise connected to a brand must be clearly identifiable as advertising. The CAP guidance says an influencer who includes an affiliate link or code is treated as an advertiser, and any content referring to that product counts as advertising [1]. Labels such as "Ad" are likely acceptable, and the label must appear upfront [1].
The same guidance lists labels unlikely to be enough on their own, including "sponsored", "gifted", "affiliate", abbreviations such as "aff", personalised discount codes and a statement in the bio [1]. It also says both brands and influencers are responsible for ensuring that ads are obviously identifiable [1]. The CMA guidance for content creators lists "ad", "advert" and "advertising" as accepted labels and warns against hiding them among other hashtags [2].
What applies to samples and brand responsibility?
The CMA counts any form of reward as payment, and gifts of products fall within that in its view [2]. Posts promoting a creator's own brand must be labelled too [2]. The CMA guidance for brands says you should have a policy setting out the rules creators should follow and make sure creators and intermediaries know about it [3].
In practice, write the disclosure rule into every brief, check posts after publication and ask creators to correct them quickly if needed. The ASA usually holds the brand at least jointly responsible, even if it did not control the specific content [1]. The guidance is advisory, so check the current wording and take legal advice if in doubt.
How does tracking work?
At selecdoo, tracking runs through a tracking pixel or the Shopify app, and orders are attributed by last click or voucher code. The voucher code often matters to creators because the community types it in instead of following a link. Run test orders to check that code and link reach the report.
On Starter, orders are confirmed automatically after 30 days, and you enter cancellations yourself. Discuss reporting openly: creators trust a brand more when they know when and why a commission lapses.
What does selecdoo cost?
On Starter you pay 0 euros platform fee per month. A 500 euro deposit is offset against your commissions, plus a 30 per cent network fee on commissions actually paid. Growth costs 859 euros a month and Scale 1,379 euros a month, each plus the network fee, billed in EUR. Notice: four weeks to quarter end.
How do creators stay with you?
Creators stay when the effort pays off. Report results back regularly, pay on time and adjust terms when a creator delivers well. A tier with a higher rate above an agreed sales threshold can motivate, but it must fit your margin. Share new products early so that content matches your promotions.
What mistakes should you avoid?
Typical mistakes are a brief that is too thin, missing disclosure, a rate without a margin calculation and late reporting. Equally problematic are statements about products that you cannot substantiate. Give creators only statements that are true, and let them describe their experience in their own words.
Who is the model not suited to?
Large creators with a fixed rate card rarely work on commission alone, because their effort and reach justify a fee. The model suits smaller creators, niche communities and customers who genuinely love the product. If you need quick reach for a launch, plan a budget for paid posts and use commission as a supplement.
How do you start without a fixed fee?
Define commission, code, brief and reporting, choose three to five creators and start small. After four to six weeks, review which codes were used, what the return rate is and how coordination is going. Then adjust terms and win further creators.
Conclusion
Commission-only works when the offer, the disclosure and the reporting are right. The model saves fixed fees but needs management and clarity on labelling. How to win publishers for it is covered on the page about how to recruit affiliates. You can Start with no monthly fee or talk through what suits your store in a Discovery Call. This article is not legal advice.
Sources
- CAP / ASA (6 August 2026, CAP Executive advice): Recognising ads: Social media and influencer marketing
- CMA (page without an update date, accessed 4 November 2026): Social media endorsements: guidance for content creators
- CMA (page without an update date, accessed 4 November 2026): Social media endorsements: guidance for brands
Note: All sources were accessed on 4 November 2026. This article is not legal advice, and the rules can change. CAP Executive advice does not bind CAP or the ASA.